Capture All is a multiyear collaboration, beginning in 2021, between Liquid Architecture (Melbourne) and Sarai (Delhi), featuring artists, scholars, and writers based in India and Australia contributing to a series of critical intensives, dialogues, public programs, and publications.

Online

The first chapter of Capture All (2021-2022) consisted of an online intensive workshop series with the artist cohort and invited guests. This built a strong foundation for identification of shared interests and concerns among the group, who sought to explore how experimental practices of sound and listening may be mobilised as resources for examining life in settler and post-colonial Australia and India. The primary outcome of the first year was the web publication of a dossier of text and sound-based artworks for Liquid Architecture’s Disclaimer journal.

INTENSIVE I – Sound, Expression, Knowledge

August 2021

Sound art in India: Panel discussion with Jeebesh Bagchi, Ish S, and Pallavi Paul

  1. Jeebesh Bagchi, Ish S, and Pallavi Paul joined us for a discussion of sound art in India, drawing on their own extensive artistic practices.

Hungry Listening reading group, and conversation with Megan Cope

  1. We discussed Dylan Robinson’s book Hungry Listening, which considers listening from both Indigenous and settler colonial perspectives.
[PDF] Robinson, Dylan. Hungry Listening: Resonant Theory for Indigenous Sound Studies. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2020  •  DOI: doi.org/10.5749/j.ctvzpv6bb
  1. Quandamooka artist Megan Cope joined us to discuss her practice and her work Untitled (Death Song), produced in 2020 as part of her investigation into listening practices and extractive industries in Australia.

INTENSIVE II – Sound, Data, Archives

October 2021

Machine Listening workshop with Sean Dockray, Joel Stern, and James Parker

  1. Machine Listening joined us to present an introduction to the Machine Listening Curriculum, followed by a preview and tutorial on the Machine Listening ‘instrument’ built in collaboration with Reduct for the filtering, processing and manipulation of speech and text.
  2. We shared and discussed our Machine Listening instrument compositions.

Machine Listening: Unnatural Language Processing – Liquid Architecture x Unsound

Unnatural Language Processing explored the history, politics and artistic potential of automatic speech recognition. Along with talks, conversations and newly commissioned audio experiments, the session officially launched the Machine Listening ‘instrument’. Featured artists included Jennifer Walshe, Tomomi Adachi, Jon Leidecker (Wobbly), Roslyn Helper, Snack Syndicate, and Martina Raponi.

‘Colonised by Data: The Costs of Connection’ – public lecture by Nick Couldry and Ulises Mejias

Nick Couldry and Ulises Mejias presented the data colonialism thesis developed in their book The Costs of Connection: How Data Colonialism is Colonising Human Life and Appropriating it for Capitalism, and their project Tierra Común.

Reading session with ADM+S researchers

[PDF] Couldry, Nick and Ulises Mejias, The Costs of Connection: How Data Colonialism is Colonising Human Life and Appropriating it for Capitalism, Redwood City: Stanford University Press, 2019
[TXT] Ricaurte, Paola, ‘Data Epistemologies, The Coloniality of Power, and Resistance.’ Television and New Media 20(4) (2019): 350-365  •  DOI: doi.org/10.1177/1527476419831640

INTENSIVE III – Sound, Location, Situatedness

June 2022

Workshop with Kush Badhwar

Artist and filmmaker Kush Badhwar joined us to discuss his practice and his film Blood Earth (2013), which documents the singing of songs written in response and resistance to conflict in Kucheipadar, Odisha, India, between the Indigenous Adivasi inhabitants and a mining venture seeking to exploit the bauxite-rich area.

[VID] Blood Earth (2013)
[TXT] e-flux interview with Kush Badhwar

Melbourne

How might we intervene in and resist perpetual patterns of capture that are increasingly abstracted, automated, and blackboxed beyond reach? Where and how do such practices relate to histories of migration in the Asia Pacific context? How is audibility understood, stretched, and counter-mobilised in relation to settler-colonial extractivism, technological control and capture, and ongoing modes of statist and corporate governance?

These questions propelled a Capture All residency in Melbourne (February 2023), hosted by Liquid Architecture, and convened by Laura McLean and Suvani Suri with cohort members Aasma Tulika, Joel Spring, Mehak Sawhney, Shareeka Helaluddin, Thomas Smith, and Uzma Falak.

During the residency, performances, lectures, and workshops by the Capture All cohort were presented at the Australian Centre for Contemporary Art (ACCA) as part of the Data Relations Summer School on Monday 20 February, 2023. This included an evening performance open to the public.

Loops, Echoes, Phonophanies, and Other Détournements

20 February 2023, 5–8pm  •  Australian Centre for Contemporary Art

Lecture and musical performance
Suvani Suri w/ Aasma Tulika, Uzma Falak, Shareeka Helaluddin, Mehak Sawhney

A drift that begins with the attempts to tune into the inaudible recordings of the Linguistic Survey of India archives, producing short circuits in the process. The slow rummaging opens up ways of listening to co-relationalities, within the archival crackles, echoic memories, archaeological artefacts, earwitness testimonies, computational instructions, and cultural data sets moored in South Asian contexts.

Capture All: Screen And Sound

25 February 2023, 2–5pm  •  Composite

Screening:

  1. Tom Smith, Narrative 001: The Things We Like, 2022 (18'45")
  2. Mochu, Cool Memories of Remote Gods, 2017 (14'48")
  3. Aasma Tulika, Listening to Success Stories, 2022 (19'23")
  4. Kush Badhwar, Blood Earth, 2013 (35')
  5. Joel Spring, DIGGERMODE, 2022 (23')
  6. Jazz Money, We have stories for all the dark spaces in between, 2021 (7'15")

Delhi

Modulating Realities: Networks of Sonic Thinking

14 & 15 December 2023  •  Sarai, CSDS

The Modulating Realities symposium focused on questions of situatedness and relationality that lie at the heart of sound and listening. Through a collection of artistic, experimental, and research practices that are working through the complexities of the aural and mediatic environments, Modulating Realities attempted to lay out and propose a potential scaffolding of what it means to think with and by means of sound in the contemporary, and not merely ‘about’ it.

What are the ways in which an auditory turn affects and constitutes relational practices and positionalities today? How does the sensorium of sound lend itself to actively probing and unsettling systems and structures of control, capture, and extraction? Can a reorientation towards the language of listening inaugurate a new vocabulary and imagination of enduring pasts and networked futures? How can sound be understood as a force field that modulates realities — both embodied and atmospheric — and as an artistic and epistemic tool that can help demodulate them?

To respond to some of these questions and concerns exploring the realm of sonic thinking, the sessions in this symposium bring together thinkers and practitioners from across artistic disciplines, sound, film and media studies, anthropology, literature, philosophy, and cultural and aesthetic theory.
 

[PDF] Program: Modulating Realities booklet

Oceanic Auralities

Mehak Sawhney, Ranjit Kandalgaonkar (presenters), Gautam Pemmaraju (respondent), Suvani Suri (moderator)

Aqua Audibilis: Sounding and Surveilling the Indian Ocean Mehak Sawhney

The dominant idea of territories and borders today is marked by the Westphalian paradigm of linear divisions amidst nation-states. Through international treaties such as the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) (1982), a similar idea was also inscribed on the maritime boundaries of states, with defined zones for territorial control and economic activity. The subsurface ocean, however, presents a different picture of militarization and territorialization. As the subsurface ocean is navigable primarily through sound, the emergence of anti-submarine warfare and underwater sonic monitoring are deeply intertwined technological histories. This presentation will focus on the mediatization of subsurface ocean through a history of sonars (Sound and Navigation and Ranging) and underwater acoustics in postcolonial India. It will propose two interrelated ideas: 1) aqua audibilis, which in tandem with concepts such as terra/aqua nullius/incognito, refers to the sonic territorialization of the previously unknowable deep ocean as well as an oceanic imagination of global sovereignty beyond the purview of maritime law, and 2) sound as border, which places sonic mediatization at the centre of border-making and unmaking in the subsurface netherworlds.

Sounding Out The Labour Archive Ranjit Kandalgaonkar

Sounding Out The Labour Archive is a sonic documentation of the ship-breaking yards at Alang and an early engagement with forms of labour involved in the large scale operations at site. The visual tropes associated with shipbreaking usually miss other scales of engagement with the site. This work seeks to acknowledge and document those other reverberating registers within the shipbreaking industry through an aural landscape. These registers for labour conditions are offered as an alternate mode to record conditions at the yard that don’t “sound” incriminating. The heterotopic space induced by these elemental conditions mark a specific moment; when objects (that were pulled together and fused to form a ship) again begin to come apart to be redistributed.

Listening to a Dig

Mochu, Joel Spring (presenters), Ashok Sukumaran and Rahee Punyashloka (respondents), Laura McLean (moderator)

GROTESKKBASILISKK! MINERAL MIXTAPE Mochu

GROTESKKBASILISKK! MINERAL MIXTAPE looks at online subcultures that perform anti-egalitarian politics by endorsing a technologically accelerated view of the world, specifically those that display an affinity towards Asian futurisms. Through a corruption of 3D real-estate renderings, Bollywood sounds, martial-arts games, and mythological comics, the video explores apolitical techno-subjectivity on the internet and its duplicitous mockery of social institutions, historical progress and cultural freedom. The curious entanglement of such subcultures with literary genres like science fiction and horror also highlights the strange historical complicity between technological fictions and anti-rationalist ideas in the public sphere.

DIGGERMODE Joel Spring

As both a standalone video work and a philosophy of enquiry, DIGGERMODE highlights the environmental impact of our digital world on Indigenous peoples who most intimately feel the growing impacts of Capitalism and climate change on their lands and ways of being. Think how mining and images of mining have shaped the way we imagine and view the world, how historical museums operated as proto-databases and how today most cultural production is now subject to metaphors that deal with software-mediated transactions.

Auditory Infrastructures

Joel Stern, Kaushal Sapre (presenters), Yashas Shetty (respondent), Thomas Smith (moderator)

A voice clone and nothing more Joel Stern (Machine Listening)

This presentation examines voice clones as material, symbolic, cultural, and political phenomena, and sites of critical and creative potential. It draws on artworks by Machine Listening, including Environments 12 (2023), which is narrated by an ensemble of clones and the human voices on which they were trained, and Machine Listening Songbook (2023), a series using clones to explore compositional and decompositional strategies in poetry and songwriting. These works attempt to shift the conversation from prevalent industry concerns over ‘vocal deepfakes’—highlighted by incidents like @ghostwriter977’s viral ‘fake Drake’ song and the 2017 ‘deepfake’ of Obama—to the clones’ intrinsic properties, their eerie unfamiliarity, their performative nature, and their innate dualities. What can we learn from intensive listening to voice clones? Might their peculiar articulations reveal insights into the ‘pathologies’ of their neural network structures and the broader social frameworks they emerge from?

temperamental server, incidental listener Kaushal Sapre

This session is about making, carrying, thinking sound through recounting experiences of running a self-hosted internet radio station from a shared studio in Delhi. radio roohafza began in 2021 as an experiment with livestreaming homemade mixes and neighbourhood noises on the internet. It has since become a vehicle for broadcasting various conversations, gatherings, zoom meetings, playlists, and jam sessions. I’d like to begin by thinking through how radio roohafza has changed my own understanding of listening in (as) a social sense.

Sonic Hallucinations and Media Archaeologies

(Public Evening) Ravi Sundaram, Ashok Sukumaran, Shikha Jhingan

The session discursively moves through certain nodes and ideas of working with sonic materials, hybrid media, data sets and information flows that produce unexpected mediatic encounters and contingent moments. What are the archaeologies that can sense this kind of a hallucination taking shape, and examine its far ranging consequences and accidental insights? Beginning with the sonic event set up by the Radia tapes and Sarai’s interests in sound collaborations beyond questions of sonic citizenship, and the new AI-driven moment, the exchange opens up a set of concerns and propositions around that which constitutes a sonic leak or break.

Algorhythmic Images

Aasma Tulika, Karthik K.G., Yashas Shetty (presenters), Sukanya Deb (respondent), Laura McLean (moderator)

Circuit breaks off beat loops Aasma Tulika

This session looks at ways in which programming of language shapes social relations, where programming is understood in the sense of applying a set of rules to carry meaning, information and signs between subjects and objects. By sampling stories from different technological histories, everyday incidents, reality TV excerpts and prevalent cultural myths, one listens for breaks in the attitude of hearing with displaced words, speech and sounds produced by mediatic environments.

When data-objects talk… Karthik KG

I imagine Sonic Thinking as the act of paying attention to the instances when data-objects talk from within the black-box of computational infrastructures. Early October 2023 saw a massive data breach surface on the darknet. It is rumoured to have revealed sensitive information of more than 800 million Indians. Starting from this incident, this presentation will move to certain moments within Karthik’s creative practice to identify instances where data-objects talk.

Notes from Utopia: Days and Nights in a Gonzo archive Yashas Shetty

This presentation will cover the folk songs of the Jhonda along with an overview of their artefacts. Numerous curious figures in Indian history including the music critic JS Saxena and the amateur archaeologist and mathematician DD Kosambi have encountered the Jhondas. The talk will focus on these encounters, construction of the archive, its history and possible futures.

Narrative Encounters

Thomas Smith, Sukanya Deb, Mohit Shelare (presenters), Ashok Sukumaran (respondent), Joel Spring (moderator)

Quantitative Collapse Thomas Smith

Quantitative Collapse is a lecture-performance extending upon Narrative 001: The Things We Like, and a more recent sequel Narrative 002: Disaster (Jackson). These works imagine a future where the production and consumption of entertainment media is dominated by a single platform, Worldio. In this future, the distinction between quantitative and qualitative data has collapsed to the point where all manner of user impressions, aesthetic preferences and responses can be measured, collated into discrete profiles, and leveraged as prompts in the automated production of media tailored to individual desires. The work and lecture-performance together expands upon present computational techniques and tendencies to imagine a ‘long term’ or telos in relation to platformed media production and consumption. What might media be in the future if we take the uncon-scious desires of platform designers seriously? Where do the many and varied techniques of platform capitalism and so-called AI converge?

The Document as a Springboard: Stitching Fragments across Time Sukanya Deb

Engaging with the form of the document and its truth claim, this presentation will explore speculative entry points for fictional forms to arise. The initial document is the National Geospatial Policy 2022 that aims to liberalise the geospatial sector and additionally create virtual replicas of major cities and towns in India by the year 2030. The presentation will consist of excavated excerpts and artefacts, through a reading of ongoing research, providing a glimpse into potential portals for exploration.

Noise cancellation apparatus and augmented association Mohit Shelare

Can waste speak beyond ecological equality and ecosystems? Deep augmented association of identities end up making new breaks and parts within our fragmented social system. Contradictions in life sound like something and act like something, theory or laws are not enough, something more is needed maybe to reduce the gap between thinking and speech.

Echoic Archives

Shareeka Helaluddin, Rahee Punyashloka (presenters), Mithran Talitha (respondent), Aasma Tulika (moderator)

No archive will restore you Shareeka Helaluddin

This is an extension of my 2022 work from Disclaimer journal, ‘Echoic Memory Song: listening for loss, grief and possibility through கீழடிKeeladi Objects’. I will be sharing a hybrid of dialogue and live soundscape performance as part of a desire to use sound as a conduit for connection, collapsing colonial bounds of time and a queering of violent, nationalist narratives. I will be attempting to delve into intimate realms of knowledge and expression, and moving through questions of archiving in relation to cultural domination and erasure, parasocial grief, and the embodiment of memory. This session invites a sensorial and affective approach to sound and ideas, and ways of engaging that are often systematically-marginalised but relate a lot to the poetic and fragmented way I comprehend the world.

Noise Reduction Or, Postulates for Anarchivic existence Rahee Punyashloka

“Noise Reduction” became a popular phrase in the last decade, owing to the proliferation of the digital image and the “noise” that came with it. The noise, a uniquely volatile structure threatened the actualizable basis of the image, and thus, softwares were created to forego this liminal entity. This “systematic erasure” of noise occurred at a time when I struggled to find an archival basis to my own frustrations around my marginalised identity. Without any readily accessible basis in explicitly anti-caste aesthetics, I saw the philosophical structure of noise as a possible point of reflection, and as a metonym for my own anarchivic existence. “Noise Reduction” was to be alternatively interpreted in a Hegelian spirit, with Reduction as meaning aufhebung or synthesis, and “noise” as referring to the proliferations of margins that can’t but be done away with for the stability of the image to persist. Working through my series of video works, Noise Reduction 1-3, I try to “remember” this moment and the anarchivic overtures that I tried to make into the questions of identity, memory, and the archive fever that surrounded our zeitgeist.

Acousmatic Voicings

Shikha Jhingan, Sebanti Chatterjee, Suvani Suri (presenters), Vebhuti Duggal (respondent), Joel Stern (moderator)

Unsettling Acousmatic Enactments: Soundscapes of Contemporary Independent Films Shikha Jhingan

This paper will focus on soundscapes of films made by contemporary independent directors who have tried to address the changing political landscape with a carefully constructed sound design. Marking a shift in acoustic territories through the use of music, acousmatic sounds, ambient noise and silence, these films show how a familiar place can feel strange and disorienting. Films like Aisee Hee (2019) by Kislay Bhattacharjee, Eeb Allay Oooo (2019) by Prateek Vats and Nasir (2020) by Arun Karthick, use immersive soundtracks that force us to listen to the shifting contours of both public and private spaces, with their characters. Geographical markers of filmed places are highlighted not just through the camera but non-human voices, sonic bodies and media infrastructures. The promiscuous quality of sound becomes a forcefield to think about the way subaltern bodies get marked or silenced in the public domain, or the way sonic practices can unsettle the public/ private distinction. How can we then rethink the formulation of the figure/ ground relationship in terms of the sonic (as opposed to the visual) especially when we consider the sharpening of gender, religious and ethnic identities amidst the rise of violent majoritarianism and its performative presence in the “everyday?” Through these discussions Jhingan will attempt to open up the debate on how attention to sound can unravel questions of the political and their entanglement with the troubled questions of belonging and citizenship.

Mapping Choral Voices Sebanti Chatterjee

Different voices offer different meanings, sentiments, and consequences in the creative process. Choral voices are usually situated within the Christian musical tradition. India poses the challenge of situating complex colonial encounters in particular socio-historical conditions. The latter shaped the interplay between the global and vernacular discourses around choral singing both within church spaces and other secular spaces. This presentation discusses ethnographic illustrations between 2013 and 2018. It addresses three central questions: 1) How to categorise choral voices? What do choral voices inform us about specific communities? Are choral voices formulating novel musical templates? Spanning Goa and Shillong, the paper explores the peculiarity of genres maintaining a balance between tradition and transformation.

(Un)Sound objects Suvani Suri

This session traces the notion of the “sound object” in historical, material and ontological terms, interrogating the fluctuating relations between the source and listening body in the course of the movement of the idea. Through a collection of recent works (in progress), concerns and questions, a map is laid out of the attributes that could possibly be assigned to the sound object in a way that destabilises the objecthood or thingness of sound, opening it up to a field of relational yet situated listening rather than affixing it to a defined form, experience or process. At the same time what needs to be ascertained are the processes of production, mediation and distribution of sonic matter and the thresholds that constitute it.

Resonant Soundscapes

Dr. Brahma Prakash, Uzma Falak (presenters), Sebanti Chatterjee (respondent), Shareeka Helaluddin (moderator)

This Chaos is “Participatory”: Reading the Vibes and Visceral Formation of Body in the Political DJ Dr Brahma Prakash

We know the colour of politics, from saffron to red and from green, white to blue and black. But do you know how they sound? Like rock or Jazz or folk or pop? Do they have different rhythms and a sense of participation? Sound is becoming a major mobilizing force in the contemporary politics of India and South Asia. Sound can no longer be sidelined in our approaches. Sound is mobilizing the body and senses at the most visceral level. Before we can recognize politics, we get its vibes. It is recognizable that from rhetoric and speech, the language of politics is moving towards sound. From mind games, it is moving towards the senses. From voice, it is moving to noise. It is not a dialogue but the decimal level—the volume decides the winnability of a debate. It is taking us in a trance. The emerging contexts show that sound is exerting its immense power on our contemporary politics. In this talk, I will discuss the visceral formation of the Hindutva Pop or what I have termed as the Disc Jockey Hindutva, I also discuss its alternative politics that not only challenges but also complicates a position that only power can play on the DJ or the DJ is necessarily a sign of aestheticization of politics. I argue that the DJ is only a sign of an intensification of politics. If the power is coming on DJ, so the alternatives, silence is the only casualty that will suffer.

Sonic Witnessing Uzma Falak

Examining multiple valences of “audible” and “inaudible”, the presentation will unfold in two parts: exploring mobilisation of sound and silence towards extraction and control through an inquiry into Hindutva pop songs and music videos – released mainly over YouTube and other social media platforms – in celebration of the revocation of Article 370 in 2019. Drawing from my doctoral research on women’s sonic praxis and sovereignty in Kashmir, the presentation will also focus on examining songs as evidence of violence and as “transcripts of resistance”– delving into women’s intimate songworlds as archives and enactments of alternate spatio-temporal imaginaries.

Data Audit / Why Listen to Datasets?

12 December 2023, 11am–2pm  •  Khoj Studios

Workshop with Joel Stern (Machine Listening)

In this experimental workshop, participants listened to datasets as sites of both power and possibility, critique and creativity. Moving between lecture, conversation, and a series of listening tests, the workshop considered how auditory datasets are compiled, stored, and processed, and how different modes of listening might reveal a world of social relations - of labour, ownership, and context - embedded within them.